Rare 2005 Nickel Error Guide
The 2005 nickel error market has gotten complicated with all the variety claims, authentication challenges, and value debates flying around. As someone who has searched countless Westward Journey nickels for errors, I learned everything there is to know about what’s actually valuable. Today, I will share it all with you.
The Westward Journey Series
Probably should have led with this section, honestly—2005 introduced two new reverse designs (American Bison and Ocean in View) plus a new forward-facing Jefferson portrait. New dies mean new opportunities for errors.
The Speared Bison
That’s what makes 2005 nickel errors endearing to us variety collectors—the Speared Bison is a recognized die gouge showing what appears to be a spear through the bison’s body. This attributed variety commands $50-300 depending on condition.
Other Documented Errors
- Die clashes showing ghost images
- Off-center strikes of varying degrees
- Doubled dies on lettering
- Clipped planchets
What’s NOT Worth Money
Minor die deterioration, machine doubling (flat, shelf-like), and normal die wear are common but worthless. Learn the difference before paying premiums or getting excited about finds.
Authentication
PCGS and NGC attribute recognized varieties on their holders. For any error worth more than the grading fee, professional certification adds both credibility and value.
