Best Place to Sell Coins Near Me

Selling coins has gotten complicated with all the options, scam warnings, and wildly different valuations flying around. As someone who has bought and sold coins for years at shops, shows, and online, I learned everything there is to know about getting fair prices for your coins. Today, I will share it all with you.

Local Coin Shops

Probably should have led with this section, honestly—local coin shops remain the most straightforward option. A good dealer evaluates your coins on the spot, explains the pricing, and hands you cash immediately.

• Immediate cash payments
• No shipping hassles
• Face-to-face negotiation possible

The downside? Dealers need profit margins, so offers typically run 10-30% below retail. Visit multiple shops to compare—I’ve seen $50 differences on the same coin from dealers two blocks apart.

Coin Shows

That’s what makes coin shows endearing to us collectors—dozens of dealers competing for your coins in one location. The competition pushes prices up, and you can get multiple offers in an hour.

• Multiple dealers, competitive offers
• Great for rare or unusual pieces
• Networking opportunities

Shows can be overwhelming if you’re new. Bring a list of what you’re selling and your target prices.

Online Marketplaces

eBay, Craigslist, and Facebook Marketplace let you cut out the middleman entirely. Set your own prices, reach buyers worldwide, and potentially get full retail value.

• Global buyer pool
• You control pricing
• Research comparable sales easily

Online selling requires effort—photography, listing descriptions, shipping logistics, and dealing with platform fees (eBay takes around 13%). Factor all that into your calculations.

Auction Houses

For genuinely rare coins—key dates, high grades, unusual errors—auction houses connect you with serious collectors who pay serious money.

• Expert authentication included
• Access to wealthy collectors
• Potential for record prices

Commissions run 15-25% of the sale price, and your coins might not sell. Best for pieces worth $500 or more.

Pawn Shops and Bullion Dealers

Pawn shops offer convenience but typically the lowest prices—they’re generalists, not coin specialists. Bullion dealers work well for common gold and silver coins where you’re selling metal content rather than numismatic value.

Local Coin Clubs

Often overlooked, local coin clubs connect you directly with collectors who buy at fair prices without dealer markups. Members genuinely want your coins for their collections, not resale margins.

Before You Sell

Get appraisals from at least three sources. Check recent auction results for comparable coins. Keep all documentation and original holders. And never clean your coins—it destroys value faster than anything else you could do.