Trusted Online Coin Dealers

Trusted Online Coin Dealers

Buying coins online has gotten complicated with all the dealer options, authentication concerns, and shipping risks flying around. As someone who has purchased from numerous online dealers, I learned everything there is to know about finding reliable sources. Today, I will share it all with you.

Why Online

Coin collecting
Numismatic treasures for collectors

Probably should have led with this section, honestly—online dealers offer inventory far beyond any local shop, often with better prices due to lower overhead. The challenge is verifying trustworthiness.

Vetting Dealers

That’s what makes due diligence endearing to us careful collectors:

  • Check BBB ratings and complaints
  • Look for PNG or ANA membership
  • Read multiple review sources
  • Verify return policies before purchasing

Safe Buying Practices

  • Start with smaller purchases to test service
  • Use credit cards for buyer protection
  • Insist on insured shipping
  • Document everything with photos

Red Flags

Prices too good to be true, pressure tactics, no return policy, and difficulty finding contact information all suggest problems. Trust your instincts.

Reputable Options

Major auction houses (Heritage, Stack’s Bowers), certified dealer networks, and established bullion dealers have reputations to protect. They’re generally safe choices for online purchases.

Robert Sterling

Robert Sterling

Author & Expert

Robert Sterling is a numismatist and currency historian with over 25 years of collecting experience. He is a life member of the American Numismatic Association and has written extensively on coin grading, authentication, and market trends. Robert specializes in U.S. coinage, world banknotes, and ancient coins.

228 Articles
View All Posts